David C. Hayes

as Gary

as Luther

as Narrator

as Rabbi

as Cletus

as Narrator

as Flinch Ruppert

as Nereus

as JJ

as Self

as Luther

as John Wayne Gacy

as Desert Man Beast

as David

as Paul Fitcher

as Detective

as Mr. Rizzowoski

as Travis

as Jacob

as Injun Joe

as Little Will

as Sam Cotrone

as Motorman Dan

as Mike

as Charles

as Rubber Love

as Ivan

as Zoltan

as Motoman Dan

as Big Joe Jefferson

as Luther

as Sluggo

as Dean Crispus / Dean Crispus, Sr. (Voice)

as Hiker

as Luther

as Lobo

as Mr. Pearson