Skyler Samuels

as Aurora Teagarden

as Aurora Teagarden

as Grace

as Jess

as Aurora Teagarden

as Gabby Petito

as Olivia Crawford

as Woman

as Lillian

as Charlotte Luster

as Sharon #3

as Kasey

as Esme Frost / Sophie Frost / Phoebe Frost

as Courtney

as Grace Gardner

as Carrie

as Jess Harris

as Bonnie Lipton

as Chloe King

as Andie Bates

as Amber

as Beth Harding

as Gigi Hollingsworth

as Maureen

as Brianna

as Mary Jo

as Ashley Blake

as Chrissy Collins

as Ruth