Matthew Lawrence

as Mike Caufield

as Self - Host

as Austin Wright

as Brad

as Richie

as Jimmy

as Nick

as Austin

as Kurt

as William

as Luke Walker

as The Cowboy

as Greg

as Davies

as Mike

as Brad Kirkpatrick

as Self - Paparazzo

as Andrew Hexley

as Matthew

as Ben Dawson

as Self - Guest

as Self (Archive)

as Self

as Jack Hunter

as Will

as Brian

as Dan Griffin

as Chris

as Lance

as Josh Baker

as Tony Longo

as Self - Contestant

as Lance

as Lance

as Scott

as Lance Truman

as Brock

as Danny Butler

as Billy

as Victor

as Chuck Shaw

as Jake Hunter

as Billy Deegan

as Jeremy

as Cowboy at Airport (uncredited)

as Dave Heinrich

as Mark Musser

as Rusty the Dog (voice)

as Dennis

as Frank Stein

as Jesse Harper

as Self

as Aaron Frye

as Matt Roman

as Sam Collins

as Sam Collins / Servo

as Chris Hillard

as Jack Hunter

as Zach Collins

as Sam Watson

as Timmy

as Joshua

as Joey at Age 11

as Young Joey

as Timmy (Wraparound Story)

as David Rothenberg

as Stevie

as Little Neal

as Self

as Matt

as Jesse Webber

as Matthew Donovan

as Banks