Amy Gumenick

as Samantha

as Sharon

as Sarah

as Carrie Cutter / Cupid

as Gilda Darner

as Natalee Holloway

as Gwendolyn Henley

as Natalee Holloway

as Danielle

as Reagan

as Lee Anne

as Charlotte

as Gwen Collier

as Emma Song

as Amanda

as Mary Winchester (young)

as Paige Sayles

as Shannon Hirschbaum

as Becca Wells

as Katrina Cooper

as Heidi Taylor