John Cullum

as Nate

as Arch Pontifex

as Self

as Yates

as Logan Zeiger

as Bob Andersen

as Daddy's Daddy

as Brigston Hadley

as Senator Beau Carpenter

as Seantor Beau Carpenter

as Harry

as Father Raymond

as Stan

as Professor Steeves

as Ted King

as The Starkeeper

as Milton

as Justice Wylie

as Richard Panatierre

as Self - Narrator

as Big Mike

as Cardinal James

as Wally

as Ed O'Malley

as Lee Garner, Sr.

as Mysterious Man

as Preacher in Nashville

as Pap Noone

as Narrator

as Other Voices (voice)

as Other Voices (voice)

as Link Curren

as Jack

as James Valenti Sr.

as Barry Moredock

as Judge Merle Coffey

as Reverend Owen Mosley

as Algernon Pendleton

as Mark Twain

as David Greene

as Harold Dorning

as Bernard Powell, Sr.

as Holling Vincoeur

as Rev. Endicott

as John O'Malley / Miguel de Cervantes / Don Quixote

as Robert Allardyce

as Ben

as Deputy Attorney General

as Stuart Cane

as Judge Howard Tainey

as The President

as Jim Dahlberg

as Elton Stuart

as Carl Sandburg

as Mr. Jamison

as Mr. Jamison

as Aaron Burr

as Edward Rutledge (SC)

as Walter

as Self

as Lawyer Royall

as Roman Captain

as Immanuel Quigley

as Self

as Laertes

as Andrew

as Self - Winner

as Self - Nominee / Performer